Sodium-ion battery breakthroughs may be key to our electric future

nanoguy

Posts: 1,355   +27
Staff member
Why it matters: Battery technology is one of those areas that is getting a lot of promising research results but very little in the form of commercial products we can use to power digital devices, electric vehicles, or off-grid homes. That may soon change thanks to sodium-ion batteries that are safer, more durable, and cheaper to manufacture when compared to conventional lithium-ion batteries.

It's no secret that lithium-ion batteries are at the forefront of modern energy storage and a key driver for electrification efforts worldwide. However, manufacturing them at the scale needed to meet growing demand seems like an almost impossible task. Lithium producers in recent years have warned the world could soon face a shortage of lithium, possibly as soon as 2025.

A big contributing factor is that lithium has gone from being a niche metal used in the ceramics and pharmaceutical industries to one of the most in-demand metals in the span of a few decades. Albemarle – one of the largest lithium mining companies in the world and the one leading the US lithium renaissance – plans to boost its production capacity to 500,000 tonnes annually by 2030 but says that still won't be enough to satisfy the projected demand.

This is where the sodium-ion battery comes in. While it hasn't enjoyed the same spotlight as lithium-ion, it's shaping up to be one of the big technological breakthroughs that can make the electrification dream a reality. Sodium-ion batteries have a similar design to lithium-ion batteries and can be manufactured using the same or similar industrial processes. In this type of battery, sodium ions replace the lithium ions in the cathode and the lithium salts in the electrolyte (the liquid that helps ferry charge between the battery electrodes) are swapped for sodium salts.

Sodium-ion batteries aren't a new concept, but the idea to manufacture them at scale has only gained traction in recent years. Sodium is significantly more abundant than lithium, so it's cheaper and easier to source while also being less vulnerable to geopolitical tensions. As of writing, the price of sodium carbonate tops out at $286 per metric ton, while battery-grade lithium carbonate costs a whopping $20,494 per metric ton.

Chemists have also found that cells with layered-oxide cathodes built using sodium don't require expensive metals like cobalt or nickel to achieve a comparable energy density to that of lithium iron phosphate (LFP) cells, which are widely used in more affordable electric vehicles.

Earlier this month, a team of Japanese researchers at the Tokyo University of Science revealed they've developed a high-capacity cathode for sodium-ion batteries using nanostructured hard carbon. The resulting cells can reach energy densities of up to 312 Wh per kg – about double that of lithium iron phosphate batteries. To put things in perspective, this is also 1.6 times the energy density achieved by the most advanced sodium-ion batteries a little over a decade ago.

Another benefit of sodium-ion batteries is their ability to withstand a wider range of operating temperatures – from -30°C to 60°C (-22°F to 140°F) or even 80°C depending on the chemistry used. This is why companies like Faradion have already started trialing sodium-ion battery installations for stationary energy storage in Australia.

Earlier this year, a joint venture between Volkswagen and JAC Group unveiled the first electric sedan powered by a sodium-ion battery. The vehicle is powered by a 25 KWh battery that offers a relatively modest range of up to 250 km (155 miles), but the two companies are touting fast charging speeds, better low-temperature performance, as well as a longer cycle life for the battery along with a slower decrease in capacity as it ages.

James Quinn, who is the CEO of Faradion, says the safety advantage of sodium-ion batteries cannot be overstated. While lithium-ion cells need to be charged above 30 percent before transportation, sodium-ion cells can be safely discharged to 0V just like a capacitor, which eliminates the possibility of a thermal runaway due to short-circuits. And as you can see in the video above, puncturing a sodium-ion cell at full charge also doesn't turn it into an incendiary grenade.

While Faradion is mostly interested in stationary energy storage for now, other companies like Natron Energy are already delving into the car industry. The Santa Clara-based startup is using a commonly produced material called Prussian blue to make electrodes for its sodium-ion batteries, which are rated for anywhere between 50,000 to 100,000 charge/discharge cycles. They can also be fully recharged in 15 minutes or less.

Natron recently entered a partnership with Clarios International to mass produce its sodium-ion batteries at the latter company's Meadowbrook facility in Michigan using the same equipment that is currently used to make lithium-ion cells. As production ramps up in the coming months, Natron says this will become the world's largest sodium-ion battery factory in the world.

How things will play out for sodium-ion batteries remains to be seen, but unlike many solutions that have yet to see the outside of a lab, they sure look promising. It all depends on how prices will fluctuate for materials as the technology matures and more factories start producing sodium-ion cells at scale.

Global production capacity is expected to reach 186 GWh annually by 2030, compared to 6.5 TWh for lithium-ion cells. This means that sodium batteries probably won't overthrow the dominance of lithium-ion anytime soon. However, they seem like an increasingly attractive alternative for a variety of applications and there is potential for them to become the go-to solution in the long term.

Permalink to story.

 
"If you want to make something as cheap as dirt then you should make it from dirt!"
-some random guy on youtube I was listening to talk about batteries

But the problem with battery manufacture is not the lithium. As a percentage of the battery, Lithium actually makes up a fairly small part of each battery. Though, it would help on a global scale if we used something else.
 
For around town/cities - especially for those in apartments that have no parking at their home to charge - a godsend - at 15 minute charge - is just having a coffee every 5 to 7 days if just taking 5Km trips at average ( 10 km return )
 
Ideally, aluminum would be the next battery tech; super-abundant, plus trivalent so 3 electrons per atom rather than one in Li/Na. But all of this is dependent on getting the lifespan. Notice, the one thing they don't mention is how many times you can recharge these new Na batteries before the full-charge capacity starts to drop. Still, that can just be research, a tiny tweak of the electrolytes was all that was needed to take Lithium batteries from a lifespan of 1,000 to 5,000 charges, but finding that tweak took a lot of effort.
 
Ideally, aluminum would be the next battery tech; super-abundant, plus trivalent so 3 electrons per atom rather than one in Li/Na. But all of this is dependent on getting the lifespan. Notice, the one thing they don't mention is how many times you can recharge these new Na batteries before the full-charge capacity starts to drop. Still, that can just be research, a tiny tweak of the electrolytes was all that was needed to take Lithium batteries from a lifespan of 1,000 to 5,000 charges, but finding that tweak took a lot of effort.

"In the UK, Technology from Faradion uses mixed-phase O3/P2-type Na-Mn-Ni-Ti-Mg layered oxide cathodes, hard carbon anodes and non-aqueous electrolytes, and has achieved a 3000-4000 cycle lifetime. Batteries based on this design are being used in trucks and e-bikes in India, where the lower maintenance requirements and higher safety of sodium over lithium-ion are key advantages."

Source : https://www.emobility-engineering.com/features-sodium-batteries/

Edit : Nothing against Techspot but above article is much more indepth and gives a far better explanation of... everything.
 
IMO, this is good news - assuming it actually hits the market.

In the meantime, I just saw this - https://www.greencarreports.com/new...es-375-miles-at-55-mph-recharges-in-6-minutes
and not to mention this company - https://graphenemg.com/graphene-products/graphene-aluminium-ion-battery/
And this - https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1141106_toyota-solid-state-ev-battery-production-idemitsu
Eventually, things are going to get better for EVs.
The last 10 years of EV development and battery technology has been nothing short of astonishing.
Though I have to say, I think we need to decide on a battery tech with the best characteristics and promise and run with it.
 
"may be", "could be", "potentially", "could potentially"(redundant expression), etc.

I've seen many article of the so-called breakthrough discovered technology for different fields that have potential to change our life and of course, NON OF THEM materialized, even after a full decade in some older cases not even after many decades. Why? Simply because people have very short attention span, and so these "news" have no accountability. The gain is to keep the people dreaming about the attractive future that put people in very...open state while the reality is ugly but demand paying money form the people for that "promised" coming of that future.
 
"may be", "could be", "potentially", "could potentially"(redundant expression), etc.

I've seen many article of the so-called breakthrough discovered technology for different fields that have potential to change our life and of course, NON OF THEM materialized, even after a full decade in some older cases not even after many decades. Why? Simply because people have very short attention span, and so these "news" have no accountability. The gain is to keep the people dreaming about the attractive future that put people in very...open state while the reality is ugly but demand paying money form the people for that "promised" coming of that future.
No, Unlike other technologies, sodium batteries are already being produced in high volume and integrating commercial products.
 
Exactly. Seems like days until something better comes along.
well, what happens is that batteru tech doesnt follow moore's law. people were saying the same thing 10 years ago about battery tech but our batteries are a lot better. This stuff takes longer to come to market but by the time it does we've heard about 10 other battery technologies.
 
I am surprised we've not had a big breakthrough in battery tech yet that consumers can benefit from.
As it turns out, making better batteries is actually REALLY hard.
For around town/cities - especially for those in apartments that have no parking at their home to charge - a godsend - at 15 minute charge - is just having a coffee every 5 to 7 days if just taking 5Km trips at average ( 10 km return )
Those without charging wont give a single flying F about what type of battery these cars have, they're gonna care about the obscene cost of using public chargers in some states, to the point that for small charges you are paying significantly more then gasoline.
 
Ideally, aluminum would be the next battery tech; super-abundant, plus trivalent so 3 electrons per atom rather than one in Li/Na. But all of this is dependent on getting the lifespan. Notice, the one thing they don't mention is how many times you can recharge these new Na batteries before the full-charge capacity starts to drop. Still, that can just be research, a tiny tweak of the electrolytes was all that was needed to take Lithium batteries from a lifespan of 1,000 to 5,000 charges, but finding that tweak took a lot of effort.
Aluminum is very promising and is already in a trial phase - this link https://graphenemg.com/graphene-products/graphene-aluminium-ion-battery/ (which I posted above), gives the details. IMO, its a very exciting battery technology.
 
I'll believe it when I see it. I've been involved in electronics since the mid 70's. I remember there was going to be a "new carburetor" that would allow you to get 50mpg.
Nuclear plants all over the world to power everyone.
Solar/wind power for everyone.
Battery improvements bla bla bla.
 
As it turns out, making better batteries is actually REALLY hard.
Those without charging wont give a single flying F about what type of battery these cars have, they're gonna care about the obscene cost of using public chargers in some states, to the point that for small charges you are paying significantly more then gasoline.
Didn't know that's the case - I assume supermarkets , Cafes would have reasonable prices to attract customers - especially customer only - or will be towed

wrote attack customers first heh heh - those 2 words pretty close

Again for cafe best for Sodium as quick charge - so no so easy if lithium
 
I'm referring to Alternative Battery Technologies obviously. One appears every day, 99.9% of which do not reach mass production for commercial viability.

Mainly because there needs to be enough demand to make mass production viable. Which is why the Federal Government should underwrite initial rollout of viable alternatives, in order to get things moving more quickly.
 
The key thing with Na-ion batteries is that unlike Li-ion, they can be manufactured from materials sourced ANYWHERE, because it uses elements that are abundant everywhere. So geopolitics are completely out of the equation, which is getting increasingly important these days.
 
Exactly. Seems like days until something better comes along.
Unfortunately, we have to wait. It also does not help that every time there is a shift of party in the WH in the US, priorities are reversed and OIL becomes the thing again. It seems there's a couple of dirt piles on the WH lawn, one labeled OIL, and the other labeled EVs, that keep getting moved around each time the "other" party takes the WH. You would think that someone would figure out that no progress is made when the WH back-tracks to the dawn of time.

I keep hoping that the EV industry gains enough traction so that the EV industry will stick their middle finger up at those who seem to think OIL is the way to go. Like @yRaz said, there has been much progress in battery technology in the last 10-years, and that progress will continue regardless of what the dolts in the WH say.
 
Back